Butt Plugs for Beginners: Sizing & Safety

Anal play is one of the areas people are most curious about and most unsure how to start safely. A butt plug is a common first toy, and with the right size, the right base and plenty of lube, it is straightforward. This guide covers the essentials — the one non-negotiable safety feature, how to size up slowly, which materials to choose, and why lube is different here. It is plain and safety-first, with nothing explicit.

Naughty Hut is 100% New Zealand-owned, ships NZ-wide and sends everything in plain, discreet packaging.

The one rule that matters most: a flared base

Before anything else, understand this: any toy used anally must have a flared base or a retrieval ring. Unlike the vagina, the rectum is open-ended, so a toy without a wide base can travel too far inside and become difficult to retrieve. A flared base is wider than the plug itself and stays outside the body, keeping the toy safely in place. This is not optional — it is the single most important rule of anal play. Every plug in the butt plugs collection is designed with this in mind.

Start small — genuinely small

The most common beginner mistake is starting too big. The area needs time and patience, so:

• Choose the smallest, slimmest plug to begin with. A beginner plug is smaller than most people expect, and that is exactly right.
• A tapered tip helps. A gently tapered shape eases insertion far more comfortably than a blunt one.
• A narrow neck (the part the body closes around) keeps a plug comfortable to wear.
• Consider a graduated set. An anal training kit offers several sizes so you can progress gradually over time, at your own pace, rather than guessing at one size.

There is no prize for going big quickly. Comfort at each stage is the whole point.

Lube is essential — and it is different here

This is the most important practical difference from other toys: the anus does not self-lubricate, so lube is not optional — it is required, and you will want plenty of it.

• Use a generous amount, and reapply often.
• Thicker, longer-lasting anal lubes are made for this and cushion better than a thin formula. The anal lube range is formulated with this in mind.
• A water-based lube is toy-safe with silicone plugs and easy to clean up; reapply as it is absorbed.
• Never rush to compensate for too little lube — add more instead.

Materials: choose body-safe and non-porous

For a toy used internally, material safety matters:

• Body-safe silicone is comfortable, flexible, non-porous and easy to clean — an excellent beginner choice.
• Glass and stainless steel are non-porous, smooth and firm, and take temperature well; they suit people who like a more solid feel and are extremely easy to clean.
• Avoid porous jelly for internal use — it cannot be fully sterilised.

Whatever the material, make sure the base is properly flared.

Using one comfortably

A calm, unhurried approach makes all the difference:

1. Relax first. Tension makes everything harder. Take your time, breathe, and only continue when you feel ready.
2. Apply plenty of lube to both the plug and yourself.
3. Go slowly, easing the tapered tip in gently and pausing to let the body adjust. Never force it — if there is pain, stop, add lube, and slow down.
4. Wear it comfortably, and remove it slowly and gently by the base.
5. Clean thoroughly before and after use with warm water and mild soap or a toy cleaner, then dry fully.

Pain is always a signal to stop. Comfortable, gradual and well-lubricated is the entire approach.

A quick beginner checklist

Get the base right, start small, use lots of lube, and never rush. Do those things and a butt plug is a comfortable, safe way to explore anal play at your own pace.

Frequently asked questions

What size butt plug should a beginner start with?

The smallest, slimmest one — smaller than most people expect. Look for a gently tapered tip and a narrow neck, and consider a graduated training kit so you can size up slowly over time rather than guessing at a single size.

Why does a butt plug need a flared base?

Because the rectum is open-ended, a toy without a wide base can travel too far inside and be difficult to retrieve. A flared base or retrieval ring stays outside the body and keeps the toy safely in place. This is the single most important rule of anal play.

What lube should I use with a butt plug?

Plenty of it — the anus does not self-lubricate, so lube is essential. A thicker, longer-lasting anal lube cushions best; a water-based formula is toy-safe with silicone and easy to clean. Reapply often.

What material is best for a beginner butt plug?

Body-safe silicone is comfortable, flexible and easy to clean. Glass and stainless steel are also non-porous and very easy to clean if you prefer a firmer feel. Avoid porous jelly for internal use.

Does it hurt to use a butt plug?

It should not. Relax, use plenty of lube, go slowly with a small tapered plug, and pause to let the body adjust. Pain is always a signal to stop, add lube and slow down — comfort is the whole approach.