Butt Plug Tails

A butt plug tail is a body-safe butt plug with a decorative tail attached to the flared base — most commonly faux fur (fox, cat, bunny, wolf, dog) or silicone (pony, pig, dragon, mermaid). The plug end works exactly like any standard butt plug; the tail itself is the aesthetic and roleplay feature. Butt plug tails are popular in pet play, kitten play, pony play, furry roleplay, cosplay, fantasy LARP, photography, and partnered kink scenes. Browse the full Naughty Hut butt plug tails range below — seven live tails from $25.99: three fox tails, two bunny tails, a unicorn tail and a rainbow tail, in faux fur and silicone on metal and silicone plug bases. We do not currently list a pony or dog tail.

Naughty Hut is a 100% New Zealand-owned online adult retailer dispatching every butt plug tail from our Aotearoa warehouse in plain, fully discreet packaging — no Naughty Hut branding on the parcel and no reference to the contents on the courier label. Every butt plug tail we stock has a clearly flared safety base, is body-safe and non-porous at the plug end — silicone or polished metal, with the exact grade named on each product page — R18 age-verified, and price-matched against any verified NZ retailer (we'll beat the price by 10%).

Quick buying guide

• First tail plug? A silicone bunny-tail plug under 3cm widest — The 9's Cottontails range. Soft tail, soft plug, easy to wear.
• Want a fluffier full-size tail? A long faux-fur fox tail on a metal plug — striking visual, popular for furry and pet-play scenes.
• Want a vibrating tail? The WhipSmart Furry Tales Vibrating Foxtail Plug ($167.99) is the only tail we list with a motor and remote.
• Want texture? Beaded or ribbed plug shafts (still with a single flared base) add extra sensation while wearing the tail — the The 9's Cottontails Ribbed Butt Plug with Bunny Tail ($25.99).
• Kitten play, puppy play, fawn play? The The 9's Cottontails Butt Plug with Bunny Tail ($25.99) is our cheapest and works for most pet, kitten and fawn aesthetics. For a fantasy look, the WhipSmart Furry Tales Unicorn Tail ($87.99).

Who butt plug tails are for

Anyone who finds the combination of a butt plug and a decorative tail appealing — for kink reasons, cosplay reasons, photography reasons, or just because it's hot. There's no specific orientation, gender, or kink identity required. Most buyers fall into a few overlapping groups: pet-play (kitten play, puppy play, pony play) where the tail is part of an ongoing dynamic; furry community members for fursona expression; cosplay and fantasy LARP players; couples adding visual play to partnered scenes; and solo wearers who just like the look. Whatever your reason, it's a valid one.

How to choose a butt plug tail safely

Six things matter most:

• Flared base is non-negotiable. The tail attaches to a flared base wider than the rest of the plug — this prevents over-insertion. The tail itself is decorative; it doesn't replace the safety flange.
• Plug material. Non-porous silicone or polished metal for the plug body. Avoid TPE, PVC, jelly or unbranded rubber for anal use. The tail material can be different — faux fur, faux fibre, silicone — because the tail doesn't go inside.
• Tail attachment. Quality tails are securely fastened or moulded to the base. Cheap tails can pull loose. Check the attachment point before first use.
• Tail length and weight. Long faux-fur tails (40–60cm) are dramatic but heavier — they pull on the plug. Consider this when choosing your plug size: a short tail on a small plug feels different to a long tail on the same plug.
• Plug size. Beginners under 2.5cm widest. Most tail plugs are designed for short-wear aesthetic play, not long-term wear — size for comfort.
• Lube. Water-based lube for silicone plugs (silicone-based lube degrades silicone). Generous application; reapply often.

How to wear a butt plug tail (the practical bits)

• Indoor-only is fine, and most common. Most tails are worn at home for partnered play, photography or solo wear — they don't need to leave the bedroom.
• Don't sit hard. The tail extends behind you and gets crushed if you sit fully back — most wearers either kneel, perch forward, or stand. This is true of all tails by design.
• Time limit. 30–60 minutes for most wearers; longer with experience. Listen to your body — remove if uncomfortable.
• Position the tail. Faux-fur tails arrive folded; gently brush them out before first use. Silicone tails hold their shape naturally.
• Photography: If you're using the tail for photography, lighting from the side highlights the texture better than head-on flash.

Care, cleaning and hygiene

The plug end and the tail end need different cleaning.

• Plug end (silicone or metal): Wash with warm water and antibacterial soap, or a sex toy cleaner. Solid silicone or steel plugs (no electronics) can be boiled for 3 minutes for full sanitisation. Pay attention around the attachment point where the tail meets the base — debris can collect there.
• Faux-fur tail: Don't submerge in water if you can avoid it. Spot-clean with a damp cloth and mild detergent. Brush gently after cleaning to restore the texture. If a deeper clean is needed, hand-wash in cool water with gentle shampoo, lay flat to dry — never tumble dry (the fur melts).
• Silicone tail: Wash like the plug — warm water and soap. Silicone tails are much easier to clean than faux fur.
• Storage: Hang or lay flat to keep the tail from creasing. Store in a clean dry pouch separately from other toys.

Why shop butt plug tails at Naughty Hut?

• 🇳🇿 100% New Zealand-owned and operated — based in Aotearoa, shipping from NZ
• 📦 100% discreet packaging — plain parcel, no branding, nothing on the courier label that identifies the contents
• 🚚 Same/next-day NZ dispatch with discreet courier delivery across Aotearoa
• 💲 Cheapest butt plug tail prices in NZ — we'll beat any verified NZ price by 10%
• 🔞 Verified R18 adult retailer under the Films, Videos, and Publications Classification Act 1993

Butt plug tails NZ — frequently asked questions

How are butt plug tails attached?

The tail is either moulded into the flared base (silicone tails) or securely fastened into a recessed mount in the base (faux-fur tails). Quality tails won't pull loose with normal wear. Check the attachment point before first use — a firm tug shouldn't move the tail at all.

Can you wear a butt plug tail all day?

Not realistically. Most tail plugs are designed for short-wear aesthetic play (30–60 minutes), not all-day wear. The tail extends behind you and prevents normal sitting; the plug itself isn't always sized for long-term wear. For all-day wear you'd want a low-profile silicone butt plug, which isn't what tail plugs are.

What materials are butt plug tails made from?

The plug end is silicone or polished metal on all seven tails we list — both body-safe and non-porous. The exact grade is named on each product page. The tail itself is usually faux fur (synthetic fibre, sometimes called "faux fox fur" or "faux fox tail"), faux fibre, or moulded silicone. Tail material doesn't go inside the body, so the body-safety rules only apply to the plug end.

Are butt plug tails just for furry or pet play?

No — plenty of wearers buy them for cosplay, photography, partnered kink scenes that aren't pet-play specific, or just because they like the visual. Pet play and furry are major buyer groups, but they're not the only ones.

What size butt plug tail should a beginner buy?

Plug end under 2.5cm at the widest point. A short to medium tail (10–20cm) on a small silicone plug is the most comfortable first tail — less weight pulling on the plug, easier to wear. The 9's Cottontails range is a popular NZ first tail.

Can I wash a faux-fur tail?

Spot-clean only if possible — a damp cloth and mild detergent. Avoid submerging faux fur if you can. If a deeper clean is needed, hand-wash in cool water with gentle shampoo and lay flat to dry. Never tumble dry — the synthetic fur melts.

What lube should I use with a butt plug tail?

For silicone-base tail plugs, use a thick water-based lube. For metal-base tail plugs, any lube type is compatible. Apply generously — the rectum doesn't self-lubricate. See our anal lubricant range.

Is shipping butt plug tails to NZ really discreet?

Yes — every Naughty Hut order ships in plain packaging with no branding and no reference to the contents on the courier label. Tail plugs are packed carefully to keep the tail from creasing. Same/next-business-day dispatch from our NZ warehouse to anywhere in Aotearoa.

Ready to find your first or next tail? Browse the full Naughty Hut butt plug tails range below, or explore related categories — jewelled butt plugs for other decorative options, non-decorative butt plugs, anal training kits if you'd like to build up your plug size first, or back to the full anal toys range. Don't forget the water-based anal lube. Need help choosing the right plug size or tail style? Our in-house educator team is here to help. Every order ships discreetly from our NZ warehouse with same/next-day dispatch and our 10% NZ price-beat guarantee.

Last updated: May 2026 · Reviewed by the Naughty Hut team