Butt Plug Tails

Butt plug tails combine sensual anal play with the fun, visual, and expressive world of roleplay and cosplay. These toys feature a comfortable, body-safe plug attached to a tail — often made from faux fur, silicone, pony hair fibre or soft plush materials. For many adults in New Zealand, tail plugs are more than just toys; they are a form of fantasy expression, sexual confidence, and playful identity.

At Naughtyhut, our Butt Plug Tails collection is curated to offer New Zealand adults the best selection of fox tails, bunny tails, pony tails, cat tails, fantasy creature tails, luxe fur styles and beginner-friendly silicone options. Whether you enjoy power play, pet play, dress-up, sensory fantasy or simply love the visual appeal of a fluffy tail plug, you’ll find a wide range of safe, comfortable and high-quality designs.

What Are Butt Plug Tails?

A butt plug tail is a butt plug with a decorative tail attached to the base. The plug itself is designed for comfortable insertion and secure wear, while the tail enhances the aesthetic and sensual experience. These toys allow users to explore fantasy roles such as fox, kitten, bunny, wolf, pony or exotic mythical creatures — or simply enjoy the visual and tactile pleasure of a flowing or fluffy tail.

Tail plugs are perfect for people who enjoy a mix of visual stimulation, body confidence and imaginative play. They work beautifully in both solo sessions and partnered roleplay.

Types of Tails You’ll Find at Naughtyhut

Faux fur fox tails — soft, fluffy and beautifully coloured
Bunny tails — round, plush pom-pom style
Pony tails — long, silky synthetic “mane” fibre
Cat and kitten tails — flexible, playful and compact
Metal plug tails — premium weight with luxurious fur
LED or glow tails — fantasy-inspired, luminous styles

With so many options, it’s easy to find a style that resonates with your fantasy or play preferences.

Why Butt Plug Tails Are So Popular

Tail plugs blend sexuality with fantasy, expression and playful imagination. They are especially popular among adults exploring:

cosplay and dress-up,
pet play and roleplay,
bedroom fantasy scenes,
submission and dominance,
photography or lingerie sets,
fun, confidence-building play.

Many users love how tail plugs help them embody a role or persona, unlocking a different energy and boosting confidence.

Others simply enjoy the aesthetic — the way a fluffy or silky tail interacts with the body visually and physically.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug Tail

The right plug depends on your comfort level, material preference and fantasy style. Naughtyhut offers multiple designs to cater to beginners through to experienced anal toy users.

1. Silicone Butt Plug Tails

Silicone tail plugs are soft, smooth and beginner-friendly. They’re flexible, comfortable for longer wear and easy to clean. Most beginners prefer silicone because the texture is gentle and the shape is non-intimidating.

2. Metal Butt Plug Tails

Metal plugs offer weight, firmness and a sleek, premium feel. The tail attachment looks exceptionally elegant with stainless-steel bases. These are best for intermediate users who enjoy pressure and fullness.

3. Faux Fur Tail Plugs

Faux fur tails are soft, fluffy and visually stunning. Fox tails, wolf tails and long plush tails are the most popular choices. They move beautifully and are perfect for roleplay scenes.

4. Pony Tail Plugs

Pony tails feature long strands of flowing, silky fibre that mimic a horse’s mane or tail. They swish and move naturally, making them ideal for pet play and fantasy dominance scenes.

5. Bunny Tail Plugs

Bunny tails are short, round and extremely cute. They’re perfect for playful fun, lingerie, photos and light-hearted roleplay.

How to Use Butt Plug Tails Safely and Comfortably

Tail plugs can be incredibly enjoyable when used properly. Comfort, lubrication and relaxation are the keys to a positive experience.

Use Plenty of Lubricant

The anus does not self-lubricate, so always apply a thick water-based lubricant to the plug and entrance. This ensures smooth insertion and reduces friction.

Insert Slowly

Move gently and allow the muscles to relax as the plug enters. Never force insertion — anal play should always feel controlled and comfortable.

Find the Best Position

Tail plugs can be inserted in multiple positions:

side-lying,
doggy-style,
standing with one leg raised,
lying on your back with knees up.

Choose whichever position allows the easiest access and most relaxation.

Wear the Tail at Your Own Pace

Many beginners wear the plug for 5–15 minutes during their first session. As comfort improves over time, you can wear it during roleplay, play sessions, lingerie photos or extended partner scenes.

Why People Love Wearing Tail Plugs

There are many reasons tail plugs are becoming more popular in New Zealand:

They Boost Bedroom Confidence

Many users feel sexy, expressive and powerful when wearing a tail. It adds a fantasy twist that encourages playfulness and creativity.

They Enhance Roleplay

Tail plugs are perfect for pet play, animal roleplay, dominance and submission scenes. The visual element deepens immersion and creates an exciting energy between partners.

They Look Stunning with Lingerie

A fluffy or silky tail pairs beautifully with stockings, underwear, crop tops or full cosplay outfits — ideal for photos, OnlyFans content, or private couple play.

They Provide Gentle Fullness

Many users enjoy the internal pressure and fullness from the plug itself. Tail plugs often have beginner-friendly shapes, making them comfortable for extended wear.

Butt Plug Tails for Beginners

Beginners often feel nervous about anal play, but tail plugs are surprisingly accessible. Many starter options include:

silicone plugs with tapered shapes,
soft faux fur tails,
lightweight designs for easy movement,
comfortable bases that fit securely between the cheeks.

These styles make first-time play simple, gentle and enjoyable.

Intermediate Butt Plug Tails for More Confident Play

Once beginners become comfortable with insertion, fullness, and movement, many start exploring intermediate tail plugs. These designs offer more intensity, visual flair, or unique sensations.

Metal plug tails for added weight and pressure
Pony tails that move dramatically when the hips sway
Thicker silicone plugs for deeper fullness
Long faux fur tails for immersive roleplay

Intermediate toys help users build confidence and embrace their fantasy persona more boldly, whether playful, fierce, elegant or mischievous.

Advanced Butt Plug Tails

Advanced users often seek more fullness, heavier materials, or highly expressive tails. These designs pair beautifully with fantasy scenes, photography, performance or deep roleplay.

Large metal plugs with luxurious faux fur
Pony tails with extra-long fibre for dramatic movement
Weighted plugs for intense, grounded sensations
Glow-in-the-dark or LED tails for playful, futuristic fantasy scenes

These toys provide an elevated experience, ideal for users who love bold visual appeal and strong internal sensations.

How Butt Plug Tails Enhance Roleplay

Roleplay is one of the biggest reasons people love tail plugs. They act as visual anchors for characters and personas that adults enjoy exploring in private or partnered scenes.

Pet Play

Pet play involves taking on a playful, animal-inspired role. Tail plugs allow users to embody:

a fox,
a kitten,
a pony,
a wolf,
a bunny,
or any fantasy creature.

The tail becomes a symbol of character and expression, helping the wearer feel immersed and confident.

Cosplay and Dress-Up

Many adults incorporate tail plugs into lingerie sets, costumes or themed outfits. Tails complement:

lace bodysuits,
stockings,
crop tops,
long socks,
ears or headbands,
harnesses,
and collars.

These combinations are extremely popular for photoshoots, OnlyFans content, or private partner sessions.

Fantasy Storytelling

Some people enjoy incorporating tails into imaginative scenes that revolve around:

dominance and submission,
training and obedience play,
animal symbolism,
exotic transformations,
or mythical creatures.

The tail becomes a visual centerpiece that reinforces the theme of the fantasy.

How Butt Plug Tails Feel Internally

While tail plugs are often chosen for their visual appeal, many users also enjoy the internal sensation they provide. Even the smallest plug adds gentle fullness that enhances arousal and increases pelvic sensitivity.

Tail plugs typically have tapered shapes that allow for smooth insertion and comfortable wear. The fullness encourages muscle engagement, which can make orgasms more intense and add a deeper dimension to sexual play.

How to Choose the Right Material

Tail plugs come in a variety of materials, each offering a unique sensation and visual appearance. The plug and the tail may use different materials, so it’s helpful to understand both.

Silicone Plugs

Soft, flexible and ideal for beginners. They offer gentle pressure and are the easiest to insert and wear for longer periods.

Metal Plugs

Firm, heavy and perfect for users who love stronger internal sensations. Metal bases also pair beautifully with luxurious faux fur tails.

Synthetic Fur Tails

Faux fur is the most common tail material. It feels soft, fluffy, and visually stunning — without the ethical concerns of real fur.

Pony Hair Fibre

Smooth, long, silky fibre that mimics the flow and movement of a real pony tail. Popular in pony play and advanced roleplay scenes.

How to Clean and Care for Butt Plug Tails

Tail plugs require different cleaning methods depending on the materials. The plug and tail should be treated differently to maintain quality and hygiene.

Cleaning the Plug

Remove the tail if detachable
Wash silicone or metal plugs with warm water and mild soap
Use toy cleaner for additional sanitisation
Ensure the plug is completely dry before reassembling

Cleaning Faux Fur Tails

Spot clean with a damp cloth
Use mild detergent if necessary
Avoid soaking the tail
Allow to air dry completely
Brush gently to restore fluffiness

Cleaning Pony Hair Fibre Tails

Use a pet brush or wide-tooth comb
Avoid wetting unless absolutely necessary
A small amount of leave-in detangler can help maintain shine

How to Store Butt Plug Tails

Proper storage helps tails stay fluffy, clean and long-lasting.

Keep the plug in a separate pouch to avoid dust
Hang long tails to maintain shape and prevent tangling
Avoid storing tails in tight, compressed spaces
Keep away from moisture, oils and heat sources

Many users store their tails alongside lingerie, harnesses, ears and other roleplay accessories to create a complete fantasy drawer or kit.

Butt Plug Tails for Couples

Tail plugs often play a major role in couple dynamics. They allow partners to explore new roles, communicate desires and build trust through shared fantasy.

Playful Dynamics

Some couples enjoy lighthearted scenarios involving teasing, dress-up or pet play. The tail adds an adorable, expressive touch to the energy.

Dominant and Submissive Play

Many couples incorporate tails into D/s scenes. The wearing partner may embody a submissive animal role while the dominant partner leads, guides or interacts with them.

Romantic or Sensual Connection

For some couples, the tail sparks conversation, vulnerability and closeness, making intimacy more open and connected.

Sex Positions That Work Best With Butt Plug Tails

Butt plug tails can be worn in almost any sexual position, but certain angles make the tail more visible, expressive and visually immersive. These positions also tend to be the most comfortable and enjoyable while wearing a plug.

1. Doggy-Style

This is the most popular position for tail play. The tail sways naturally as the hips move, creating a vivid and highly erotic visual effect for both partners.

2. Standing From Behind

Standing positions make the tail hang elegantly and emphasize movement. This works especially well with long fox or pony tails.

3. On Your Hands and Knees

Perfect for pet play, submission scenes or cosplay. The partner can interact with the tail directly, pulling, stroking or guiding gently.

4. Side-Lying

A great position for beginners or gentle play. The tail rests softly across the hips or thighs, creating a cute and intimate visual.

5. On Your Back With Knees Up

This position gives the partner a clear line of sight to the tail and plug, making it ideal for photos, videos or teasing.

The Visual Appeal of Tail Plugs

One of the biggest reasons tail plugs are so popular is the visual excitement they bring to sexual play. The tail becomes part of the body’s silhouette — adding movement, softness and expression.

Whether fluffy, swishy, long, short or brightly coloured, tails create a fantasy element that elevates arousal and emotional connection.

Camera-Friendly for Content Creators

Tail plugs are extremely popular in online content creation. Creators on OnlyFans, Fansly and other platforms frequently use tail plugs because:

they photograph beautifully,
they add personality to content,
they draw attention to the hips and curves,
they help build a themed identity or persona.

Many models pair tail plugs with ears, harnesses, thigh-high socks or themed lingerie to create cohesive fantasy sets.

Butt Plug Tails in BDSM and Sensation Play

Tail plugs often appear in BDSM scenes because they merge physical sensation with psychological immersion. The wearer might take on a submissive role, while the partner enjoys the symbolic and aesthetic appeal of the tail.

Light Dominance Scenes

Tail plugs are used in gentle scenes involving:

commands,
leading by the tail (very gently),
petting or stroking,
obedience play.

Deeper Roleplay

More involved scenes may include:

pet training,”
costume elements like collars and ears,
bondage accessories,
behavior-based games.

The tail becomes part of the wearer’s role identity — playful, obedient, mischievous or sensual.

The Emotional Side of Wearing Butt Plug Tails

For many adults, wearing a tail is not just sexual — it is emotional and expressive. Some people feel cute, soft, playful or confident in a way they don’t experience in their daily life.

A tail can help people:

express a fantasy identity,
feel empowered or adorable,
explore soft submission,
enjoy creative erotic self-expression.

Whether used alone or with a partner, a tail becomes a symbol of personal exploration and pleasurable transformation.

How to Know Which Plug Size Is Right

Butt plug tails come in a range of sizes to suit all experience levels.

Small Plugs

Ideal for beginners. Usually tapered and gentle, providing light fullness and easy wear.

Medium Plugs

Great for users with some experience. Offer more fullness while still comfortable for longer sessions.

Large Plugs

Designed for advanced users or for people who enjoy intense fullness. Best worn during shorter or more deliberate scenes.

Choosing the right size ensures comfort and confidence during roleplay.

Best Lubes for Butt Plug Tails

Lubrication is essential for comfortable insertion. The best choices depend on the plug material.

Water-Based Lubes

Safe for all materials including silicone, metal and faux fur bases. Easy to wash off and ideal for beginners.

Silicone-Based Lubes

Only use these with metal plugs. They provide long-lasting glide but can damage silicone toys.

Hybrid Lubes

A blend of water and silicone, offering smooth glide and easy cleanup. Suitable for metal or ABS plugs.

Avoid getting lube on the fur or tail fibres to keep them fluffy and clean.

Confidence, Self-Expression, and Fantasy Empowerment

Butt plug tails help many users tap into a part of themselves that feels free, playful and expressive. Whether it’s a cute bunny persona or a confident fox energy, the tail becomes a physical extension of the fantasy.

This self-expression often boosts sexual confidence and creates memorable, emotionally rich experiences for both solo and partnered play.

When Not to Use a Butt Plug Tail

While tail plugs are safe when used correctly, there are a few situations where you should pause or modify play.

If you feel sharp pain or burning
If you have active anal injuries or severe hemorrhoids
If the plug is too large for your current comfort level
If the tail gets caught, pulled harshly or handled unsafely

Always prioritise comfort and safety — roleplay should be fun, not stressful.

Tips for Beginners Experimenting With Tail Play

Tail plugs can feel intimidating at first, but starting gently makes the experience enjoyable and safe.

Start with a small silicone plug
Use a thick water-based lubricant
Insert slowly, allowing the muscles to relax
Wear the tail briefly at first (5–10 minutes)
Practice walking, crawling or posing with the tail
Experiment with positions that feel natural

As comfort grows, you can explore larger plugs, heavier tails or more elaborate roleplay.

Advanced Roleplay Ideas With Butt Plug Tails

Once you’re comfortable with the basics of wearing a tail plug, you can explore richer, more immersive roleplay scenarios. These styles allow couples — or solo players — to build deeper storytelling and emotional connection.

1. Fox or Wolf Fantasy Play

Fox tails and wolf tails are some of the most popular styles in New Zealand. These scenes focus on confidence, sensuality and primal energy. A fox tail can represent playfulness, seduction or clever mischief, while a wolf tail implies strength and boldness.

2. Kitten Play

Kitten tails are shorter, cute and perfect for lighthearted fun. Pair the tail with cat ears, a choker, soft makeup or playful behaviour to create an adorable, flirty persona.

3. Bunny Roleplay

Bunny tails match beautifully with lingerie, thigh-high socks and soft pastel accessories. The short pom-pom tail adds charm and sweetness to sensual scenes.

4. Pony Play

Pony tail plugs are ideal for power-dynamic scenes where one partner takes on a strong, graceful or obedient persona. Pony play often involves:

long pony tail plugs,
harnesses,
reins or light guidance,
movement-based activities.

The long tail sways beautifully with every step, making this one of the most expressive fantasies to explore.

5. Fantasy Creature Scenes

Some tail plugs are designed with unusual colours, glow effects or unique textures — perfect for creating a mythical or otherworldly persona. Think dragons, magical foxes, alien creatures or neon-fur beings.

How to Involve a Partner in Tail Play

Butt plug tails open a door to shared creativity between partners. Communicating your desires upfront increases comfort, closeness and enjoyment.

Have a Conversation First

Before using a tail plug with a partner, discuss boundaries, comfort levels and what type of roleplay you want to explore. Even simple discussions help build trust.

Start Light, Then Add Complexity

Many couples begin with simple teasing or wearing the tail during intimacy. As comfort grows, you can transition into:

obedience games,
guided movement,
photography or posing,
pet-themed behaviours,
dominant and submissive dynamics.

Let the Tail Guide the Scene

Some partners gently stroke, pull (always softly), or guide the tail to encourage movement or express affection. The tail becomes an emotional tool for interaction, not just a sexual one.

How to Pose, Move and Play With a Butt Plug Tail

Exploring movement is a big part of tail play. The way the tail sways, bounces or flows can shape the mood and expression of the scene.

Swaying your hips creates a seductive rhythm
Arching your back emphasises the tail’s shape
Crawling enhances pet-play personas
Slow walking shows off long tails elegantly
Bending forward enhances the visual appeal during sex

These movements create dynamic, expressive visuals that deepen immersion and pleasure.

Wearing Butt Plug Tails for Longer Periods

Some people enjoy wearing tail plugs during roleplay scenes that last 10–60 minutes or more. The key to comfortable long-term wear is choosing the right plug size and shape.

Tips for Longer Wear

Choose a lightweight silicone plug for extended sessions
Avoid large or heavy plugs unless experienced
Take breaks during long play sessions
Reapply lubricant if needed
Be mindful of body signals

Wearing a tail should always feel playful, not painful.

Using Butt Plug Tails With Other Toys

Many users pair tail plugs with other sex toys for layered stimulation. Some popular combinations include:

Clitoral vibrators for enhanced external pleasure
Penis strokers for dual stimulation
Prostate massagers worn with smaller tail plugs
Wands and bullets to increase arousal during roleplay

The tail adds expressive beauty while other toys bring deeper sensation.

Cleaning and Maintaining Faux Fur & Pony Tail Fibres

Tail maintenance is important for keeping the fur or fibre looking fresh, fluffy and soft. Quality faux fur can last for years with proper care.

Keeping Faux Fur Fluffy

Brush gently after each use
Store the tail in a breathable bag or hang it
Keep away from oils, lubes and moisture
Use a hair dryer on cool setting to restore fluffiness

Caring for Pony Tail Fibres

Use a wide-tooth comb or pet brush
Apply a tiny amount of detangler spray if needed
Don’t submerge the fibres in water
Store stretched out to avoid kinks

Internal Links to All Related Anal Collections

Butt Plug Tails fit beautifully into Naughtyhut’s full Anal Toys range. You may also enjoy exploring:

Final Thoughts: Why Butt Plug Tails Are a Favourite in NZ

Butt plug tails blend fantasy, sexuality, expression and playful energy into one beautiful accessory. Whether you’re exploring fox play, kitten play, pony play or simple sensual dressing, tails are one of the easiest ways to add excitement and confidence to your intimate life.

They offer gentle fullness, stunning visuals and endless creative possibilities — from private bedroom play to themed photoshoots and sensual roleplay with a partner. At Naughtyhut, we offer high-quality silicone and metal tail plugs with soft faux fur, silky pony fibres and fantasy-inspired designs to help every New Zealander explore their playful side in comfort and safety.

Dive into our collection and discover the tail that matches your personality, your fantasy and your pleasure journey — all with fast, discreet shipping across New Zealand.